- Now that Hertz has killed off their hourly car share scheme need a replacement for something in NYC for less than full day vehicle needs. Everything went smoothly. Network is good. enterprise will let you take the key out of the car, which is nice. In your experience, was rates were you seeing when trying to rent for a long weekend? My math would indicate Zipcar stops being cost-effective after about 5 or 6 hours. Car Selection for Enterprise Car Share vs Zipcar While specific selection will depend on your location, Zipcar as a whole, offers more than 50 different makes and models. Also, I'm not finding anything near a $160 price, so I'm wondering what I'm doing wrong in shopping around. Weekend rates are high for zipcar and limited mileage included. There would frequently be issues with the cars. Zipcar is really good about giving you specific instructions as to where the cars are and how to get in/out. But thanks for sharing the story, this is exactly what I was trying to find out. We spent $40 for gas, and since I rented via Costco, 1 additional driver is included for free. How to join: Sign up at the Enterprise CarShare site. The r/nyc companion for all your NYC-related questions. It was an ad on the CTA. One annoying thing with Enterprise is they aren't very specific with where their spaces are, they just give an address. Bottom line: The CarShare isn't as attractive as it's advertised to be. Users must be 18 or over and have a valid driver’s license and a major credit card in their name. Enterprise or Zipcar? https://bestcompany.com/car-sharing/company/enterprise-carshare when it came down to it, zipcar simply has significantly more cars. Carsharing seemed to have more freedom, which I liked. Both services have cars near where I live. Even with full insurance coverage. For what it’s worth I rent Alamo from LGA all the time. Each time this would result in a 15 minute call with their customer service people to make sure I wasn't blamed for it. At first iGO was bad after the Enterprise takeover but they have made some huge improvements and have addressed a couple of key issues. Zipcar One of the first companies to bring car sharing to the city, Zipcar is one of the largest services in the world. CarSharing allows authorized employees access to on-site vehicles anytime they need them. Have been reading online reviews of Enterprise … Maybe joining a car-sharing service like Turo or Zipcar could be right for you. One of Zipcar’s competitors in the car rental space is also i the race for car sharing too. If you need a car for under an hour, these services will definitely save you. Once approved, an Enterprise Carshare membership card (which like Zipcar’s, unlocks the vehicles) … When I called up, they stated this is no longer possible. Finally they changed the car that I usually rented (the one nearest my house) with an SUV that costs $2 more per hour to rent. Just a side note - Avis rentals cover other members of the household at no extra charge. Just a nice little touch that made me prefer Zipcar more. Any suggestion where to find these silvercar discounts? "Claiming Enterprise locations are in bad parts of town may be true where you live." There are some vans and a few trucks too and even like BMWs for like $15 an hour iirc (mostly downtown). Automated vehicle technology allows employees to scan into the vehicle they need for the job and go! Enterprise Car Share works pretty similarly to the other Zipcar alternatives that have been mentioned. So, I knew there was going to be some additional charges, but gas would be included. I'd recommend Hertz or Enterprise if they have a facility near your city. Here is my brief video of my experience! Enterprise: Unlimited mileage, except in some states. For traditional rental cars, I'm not seeing anything cheaper than that besides what you already mentioned on Kayak, but like I said, that is very far away. Averages $10 an hour/$70 a day I think (depending on vehicle type and quality) and they pay gas and insurance. Our trip was going to be at least 450 miles round trip, and we only had 400 miles (200 miles/day for 2 days) included. Where they differ in benefits are the actual plans and potentially the pick up locations. We were traveling out of state and wanted to pick up the car Friday night at 7PM and drop it off on Sunday at 11PM. **Please** [read the sidebar](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/wiki/sidebar) before posting! That's what many people are suggesting, so that may very well be what I do. Zipcar: The cars are always clean, being detailed regularly by their garages’ staff. Enterprise CarShare and Carpingo both waive the first year annual fee for their lowest membership levels, while Zipcar charges a $60 annual fee. The car was a little filthy (was parked under the El on a rainy day - rusty water everywhere), but was fine. A variety of makes and models are parked in your community – where you live, and where you work – and are accessible 24/7. I'm so sorry you had that experience! I know Zipcar has a pretty extensive network, but how is Enterprise's? Almost $100 saved for slightly more aggravation (had to pick up/drop off from LGA vs across the street). I like Enterprise for rental cars. I tried looking and all I got were discounts for new users, but I’ve used them before and loved it, except for the price of course... I’m checking them out now. So I cancelled. Use it for large grocery runs and vet trips and also going to the burbs now and then. though once you get used to using your card to lock/unlock the zipcar it really isnt an issue. since I rented via Costco, 1 additional driver is included for free. And there would be issues with people not returning cars on time, the car reeking of cigarette smoke, the interior covered in dog fur. ... Zipcar vs car ownership Save an average of more than $600 per month 1 with Zipcar. I was sure to clarify this when they told me since I was under the impression it was only applicable to your spouse, but my fiancee (at the time) was covered and could drive a rental under my name even though we weren't married. After some wrangling with the customer service, I eventually got a fair amount of credit after the fact. Though I have also heard that some kind of pay-as-you-drive insurance exists now but know no details. It's not something I use as my "go-to", but it's nice to have and for $10/year, I'm not sweating it if I don't use it that often. You do need to pay a membership and application fee with Enterprise Car Share. Streamline and automate your business transportation with Enterprise CarShare. the enterprise website was also trash compared to zipcar's. So, all in all, we were looking at roughly $325 including gas. Rental Car Discussion - Car Share Best of What Is Left. With that extra info, would you still suggest renting a car? I've been a zipcar member for years, but I simply stopped after UberX became widespread. Enterprise CarShare is an automated way to rent a vehicle by the hour, the day, or overnight. Same here, the only reason I use Enterprise though is they have the closest locations to my house. Renting a car from Budget or Enterprise is usually cheaper per day on paper, but remember that ZipCar pays for gas. Aside from that, I've used zipcar when in other states. Is there something I should know about Zipcar that makes is just so much better than Enterprise? So, I'm just looking for pros and cons. If you need something bigger, they also offer vans. They've made huge updates to the website and the mobile application. CarSharing allows authorized employees automated access to on-site vehicles anytime they need them. How does Enterprise CarShare work? Like ZipCar, it’s one of the few services that includes gas, but there is a membership fee that varies depending on your Enterprise CarShare location. You don't have to worry about reservists booking right behind each other. For a 3 day trip you're better off renting from a rental car company. We're looking to go out of town next weekend, but every place I've looked at no longer has cars available, which is unfortunate. During Sandy I rented a car from Hertz for four days for about $160 and used it to haul equipment from my clients offices to where I was living at the time in Westchester, on any given Saturday, renting a car from Zipcar would cost about the same. Car sharing is great man. Thing was, they'd call you at, like, 4:30 in the morning. The $40 yearly membership fee was waived for the first year. I have no idea if they still do that, because I quit after that. Apparently i'm in their top tier of members because I got an invite to their 15th anniversary party in the loop. Previous and Ongoing Efforts . Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. This has been asked before on this sub, but most recently two years ago, and I'm sure things have changed. Start Car Sharing Link opens in a new window i live on lake/michican and there were only like 2-3 enterprise cars within 5 blocks. when it came down to it, zipcar simply has significantly more cars. So if you ever want to have 3 drivers on a rental and the third doesn't live with you, you should be able to just use your Costco perk on them and have both additional drivers for free. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Apply online with a valid driver's license. Renting from an airport or taking a train outside of the city will definitely net you the cheapest price, but my experience is that the savings aren't worth the time & hassle. I can't be the only one, right? Thanks for the info! I was an IGo member years ago, but I've heard mixed reviews since Enterprise took it over. So, even if I Uber'd to the airport for $25, we were still looking at $240 vs $325+. Throw in the gas burnt (and this is the variable here - but lets say round trip to burbs) and you're right back at $50-60. I also wanted to share driving with my fiancee, and part of their FAQ stated that you could add additional drivers onto the account. Only used it once to rent a car for a few hours. The only issues I've really had are really issues with the other people taking out cars. Blog. Between this and Uber etc owning a car has never been less necessary. Zipcar: Two plans; the occasional driver package costs $65 annual, with weekday rates from $9.00 per hour and $12.50 on the weekends. At $70 a day, Enterprise Carshare would net us about $210, plus going over the 200 mile limit would put us a bit over, but not too much. Zipcar stops being cost effective if you do multi-day rentals. I think the overages were like $0.45/mile which was going to be another $25. Based off of all the information I could find before becoming a member, I found that the Enterprise CarShare was better. Thanks. It also can really just end up coming down to which one is closer to you and/or has better cars that seem to remain in their spots more often (in order to gauge general availability at any given time). I don't remember if they actually checked when we rented, but I imagine they'd verify this by being sure both drivers have the same address on their license. I've been using Getaround for a bit now. What I found out was that on the weekends (Friday - Sunday), that rate of "$70/day" goes up to $110+/day. Car share provides another option for local trips and facilitates shorter trips, which may make it easier to access local business districts. March 5, 2021. I'm also sort of interested in using cars when traveling. Kayak had pretty good prices, I'll admit, but it's not very easy for us to get to the airport; it's over an hour away. Enterprise: My most recent Enterprise car’s exterior and glass were covered in salt residue. I outright own a truck and I spend probably $200 a month on gas and insurance and it's handy to have when I want it - but it mostly sits parked outside every day. I did Uber home (took the subway to pick it up) for $15. That, plus the fact that gas is included with Enterprise and Zip, made me feel that was the better option. Plus, my fiancee could drive. I don't know if it only covers one other member of the household, or all members, but either way at least one additional driver would be free. I can also now click one button to navigate using google maps to get back to the car location. enterprise will let you take the key out of the car, which is nice. Our grand total was going to be $300. Traditional car rentals are based on warehousing cars at airports and on low-cost land elsewhere. Owning a car: Press J to jump to the feed. Hey everyone. That could save you some bank if you kept yours. Their service, though, was terrible. They charge locals something like a $200 deposit but you do get whatever rate that’s quoted on the website when you book. If you own a truck in the city, you might want to: Sign up with Dolly to get some extra cash (if you have the time), Sign up with Metro Mile (since you don't drive much, the per-mile-insurance model makes sense for you). Car-sharing guide: On-demand, short-term car rentals. HOLY SHIT, no. it wasnt even close. i think enterprise was cheaper but not by much, only about a dollar or so per hour. We use Enterprise generally about once a week. So, I used my Costco card to login to the their travel portal and check the prices for rental cars for that same date/time range and pick up it from LGA. Any bad experiences with either? Got approved and got my card about a week or so later. Other car rentals in Brooklyn are at least $250, PLUS I have to drop them off in the late afternoon on Monday, which doesn't really work for our schedule. Zipcar is the world’s leading car-sharing network. There’s a (Hertz, I think) rental office right near the Metro-North station and you can save the time and money it takes to get a ride to and from HPN. Once you’re approved you use your computer or mobile app to reserve a car the moment you need one. Consider the payment structures of the different plans available with both providers to see which would work better for you. I probably called them every time I used a car for a couple months. A new report on the adoption and use of ride-hailing […] Enterprise CarShare is an automated way to rent a vehicle by the hour, the day, or overnight. No membership fees either. I've never been late, but I've definitely wasted 15 minutes waiting around on someone who was. Press J to jump to the feed. Enjoy the benefits of a corporate fleet without the cost of ownership! While I've heard Zip may be a bit more convenient and have better car choices, I'm still leaning towards Enterprise for the aforementioned reasons. If you want any insurance coverage beyond basic rental car damage, you have to pay extra. I'm taking a trip with my roommate next weekend (3 day weekend), and I wanted to ask you which of the two above options is better for longer trips. I went with Zipcar mainly because I got a good deal through my university. While I've heard Zip may be a bit more convenient and have better car choices, I'm still leaning towards Enterprise for the aforementioned reasons. I work downtown so if I had a car it would be the same deal; sitting there costing me money most of the time. I'm leaning towards Enterprise because they have a promotion right now waiving the $40 yearly membership fee, they offer 200 miles a day as opposed to Zip's 180, and their hourly rate is cheaper. Car sharing is based on cars parked within … i remember the enterprise gas refill being more convoluted than the zipcar one. Round Trip. Who's used both Zipcar or Enterprise recently, or feels particularly strong about one or the other? I've used zipcar extensively. How Zipcar works. I called them a couple times this year to report dents and scratches. Each rental vehicle at Enterprise is thoroughly cleaned between every rental and backed with our Complete Clean Pledge. Learn about Enterprise CarShare › You can find cars of all sizes. So even if you just go directly through Avis, instead of via Costco, your fiancee should be covered free of charge as long as you both live together. The 15 minute thing is great if you happen to be running late. Vehicles are parked in your community–where you live and where you work–and are accessible 24/7. So, all I had to pay was the $25 one-time app fee. Reservations now have a fifteen minute gap in between. though once you get used to using your card to lock/unlock the zipcar it really isnt an issue. For weekend trips, I use kayak.com to find reasonably priced cars for rent from JFK and LGA airports. I've had few issues of any sort and am pretty happy with the service. What is car sharing? When I finally logged into the app and tried to reserve a car, I got a rude awakening. Round trip; Dedicated Zipcar; Join in minutes. Also, for an official rental car, I'd have to pick it up/drop it off at designated times, which I can't predict at the moment, unfortunately. I don't care because I was using my Chase Sapphire card, and I have car insurance, so I didn't need to elect them. UPDATE: Enterprise Car Share emailed me June 28, 2017 to announce they are pulling out of the SF market. Zipcar’s model really works best for short trips of an hour or two—where it doesn’t make sense to pay $35 or so for a car just to run errands. Weighing the options, carsharing prices seemed comparable to renting, but not paying for gas was a nice bonus. It's nice since the cars are owned by real people, you can sometimes get around dealing with some corporate helpline when there is a problem. My general rule of thumb is that if you're traveling within the mileage limits for ZipCar, it's the best way to go. … Zipcar stops being cost effective if you do multi-day rentals. Zipcar should be used for day trips (hours, not overnight), otherwise you'll be spending hundreds of dollars. Some of the Yelp reviews about the condition of the cars is worrisome. I'm leaning towards Enterprise because they have a promotion right now waiving the $40 yearly membership fee, they offer 200 miles a day as opposed to Zip's 180, and their hourly rate is cheaper. 6 things your team needs to know before attending a virtual client meeting I can't seem to find that perfect combination of time and distance to where a zipcar is cheaper than an Uber and cheaper than a $50 24 hour rental from a traditional rental car company. The ultimate guide to teaching online; March 5, 2021. I wandered around a parking garage for 10 minutes trying to find the cars once. In my experience, iGO got much worse after the Enterprise take over. I don't think the company is to blame for all of the car problems, necessarily, but they had a huge membership push for a while, which just brought in too many people for them to handle all the issues. Not sure how this would work if there were 2+ additional household members who could drive as well. The rate difference between booking a rental car through Costco Travel and places like Kayak/etc will pay for the membership itself in 1 trip. That does sound awful. (Enterprise … I think it's a near-universal occurrence. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I tested out the Enterprise CarShare Service in Denver, CO. Thanks! They would call you starting two days before the reservation with a reminder. So either she'd have to sign up for an account and only be the driver, or when I reserved under my account, I would only be the driver. For longer trips (i.e. A side-by-side comparison. If you're traveling to another city but don't need a car while you're there, doing two one-way rentals is often the cheapest option. It's cheaper up-front, and you'll earn bonus credits towards all types of future rentals. This article first appeared on Planetizen at www.planetizen.com Useable data of the effects of ride-hailing service on travel behavior is sorely lacking, but a new study sheds light on critical questions about what companies like Uber and Lyft mean for transit, active transportation, and congestion. Zipcar: Limited to 180 miles per day. Although you can't extend within 15 minutes of another reservation at least it prevents someone from reserving right behind you. i live on lake/michican and there were only like 2-3 enterprise cars within 5 blocks. Budget has good deals on one-way rentals. Zipcar stands alone, so there's not much draw if you're a frequent user. They both have a one time membership application fee of $25, but be forewarned I heard from a friend ZipCar is more stringent with applicants who have points on their driving records than Enterprise. This. Car Sharing is Smart Business . Car share also has the potential to reduce annual transportation expenses for families. The only really annoying issue I had was when I reserved a zipcar once at the boston airport when I flew there, only to find the car wasn't properly configured, and therefore was unusable. Yeah, almost everyone is telling me to go for a standard rental car. Lose the payments, keep the car. What I liked about carsharing is that there were plenty of cars just a few blocks away, which sounded great. I haven't used their car-share service, but I assume the level of service would be same. I was a member of Zipcar for a few years, and I found that their day rates were very competitive especially when gas was approaching $5/gallon about 10 years ago. it wasnt even close. Ended up renting a nice VW Passat from Avis (vs the Toyota Corolla that CarShare had) for $160 total. zipcar probably has 15-20. outside of that theyre pretty similar. But I've never rented a car or done carsharing before. P.S. Use the app to book a car and use the card key provided to unlock it. /r/Chicago is the place to discuss and stay updated on the daily happenings of Chicago, Illinois, USA. zipcar probably has 15-20. outside of that theyre pretty similar. You can pick up a 24 hour rental from Enterprise (non-car share, regular) or on RelayRides for about $30/days. Catskills and beyond), a traditional rental car is best. We give you on-demand access to drive cars by the hour or the day in cities, airports, and campuses around the globe. Enterprise CarShare, the newest business to get into the D.C. market, isn’t quite as helpful for travelers. Anything that requires less hassle. I've had no experience with enterprise, but am curious to hear what others have to say. The mobile app has been overhauled to not only look modern yet to provide better features for locating your reservation, updating your reservation and checking to see if there are any alternatives. As the concept of car-sharing becomes more popular, Zipcar now faces more formidable competition from car rental giants like Enterprise and Hertz, which … Learn more about the benefits of car sharing versus car ownership and how Zipcar can help save you time, money, and headaches. I think I'll definitely go with a rental car, though. Take the Metro North to Westchester County Airport, requires a quick Uber/Lyft ride but the savings are phenomenal. Hertz 24/7 has no … had zipcar and enterprise both for about a year, just renewed my zipcar, got rid of enterprise. To access vehicles in its other cities, you must join the local program there. However, if you plan to do a lot of driving and you have a AAA membership, renting may be a better choice. This includes washing, vacuuming, general wipe down, and sanitizing with a disinfectant that meets leading health authority requirements, with particular attention to more than 20-plus high-touch points. Enterprise CarShare looked pretty good when I was comparing online, so I'm really glad I asked this question. Even without any coupons, they seem cheaper that Enterprise Rent-a-Car for the dates I chose. They have dedicated parking spots, cheaper rates, and there was one located right around the corner from where I live in LIC. (You either waste a ton of time or blow your margins by taking a taxi. We got damaged cars, the car we reserved wasn't described correctly, and the last straw for me was about six or seven years ago when Avis first took over. Ugh. Originally part of Enterprise Car Rental’s overall business, Enterprise Car Share has acquired smaller vehicle sharing companies and grown into its own entity, with service in 13 U.S. cities, Canada, and the U.K. and at more than 130 U.S. college campuses. YMMV.). At less than $10 an hour (and without the hassle of dealing with gas), Zipcar’s a better choice for a quick outing—and even … Your car spends a lot of time just sitting. I looked at Enterprise's standard rental service, and their daily rates were higher than those with their CarShare service. Once they knew about problems, it'd take them a week to fix it, during which time the car wouldn't be available to rent, so I'd have to go with one that was 1/4 mile further away. Zipcar member here. I usually don't have an issue getting a car. So, I actually was in this boat a few weeks ago. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Watch how it works. Daily … The Chicago car-sharing program features three different plans, starting at $6.75 per hour plus 40 cents per mile. Also, get a friend with a Costco card or get one yourself. Running short errands, that sort of thing.

Des Moines Register Milestones, Sidelight Curtain Rods Walmart, Revolver Magazine Tool, Performance Filtration Group, Boston Council Tax 2019/20, Hoe Ontstaat Kanker In Je Lichaam,