PS and for the record :) The ones I respect the most are indeed S2 and E1… not that that makes them an item, but I dig em more than the others… where naturally E2 is at the bottom. He realizes it and after a minute readily accepts it as if he also knew all along too because he has to. People morphing into other people. That sort of messing around is the very thing Sophie mentions missing. My man Lux, has a point. When Ethan-B is running for the force field, the Sophie on the left asks–“What will happen?” and the one on the right says “I don’t know.” This implies that Sophie-Left is Sophie-A (asking the person for info who has been around longer). At the end I’m 99.9% sure he leaves with Sophie-B just watch the end again when Ethan-A looks at both Sophie’s he’s confused at which is which. Your email address will not be published. If he had been the slightest bit open to the idea of being intimate with Sophie B, I got the impression it would have been game on. Though I see where advocates of the Ethan A/Sophie A theory are coming from when it comes to Sophie A cooking Ethan A bacon as a sign that she’s willing to try on her part, I find that Ethan A’s body language in the final scene is pivotal in determining which Sophie came back with him. To get a fulfilling and coherent explanation of the film, it’s worthwhile to use a metaphorical reading of the many incongruous events to bring in the richness of the themes. They stay there. Still, if you want the full surprise, you've been warned.). Left side Sophie gives the Sophie nod, the same one she gave back at the house to tell Ethan A, wordlessly, that she wanted to be with him. But…. This movie certainly is a beautiful one. The One I Love is a 2014 American thriller film directed by Charlie McDowell and written by Justin Lader, the film stars Mark Duplass and Elisabeth Moss. I suggest you brush up on what the word “penultimate” means. It’s my opinion that not revealing core secrets of a story is just lazy writing: any fool can make a puzzle where the pieces don’t fit. ….BUT whatever that may be, I am quite sure her motivation was NEVER to take over S1’s life and be with E1 for the rest of her life living it out as a fake. The only confusing thing is how the B’s transformed and if it was Sophie B, will she stay that way? I made my friend watch this movie and she strongly believes that Ethan 1 left with Sophie 2 but I feel like its one of those movies where the ending is up to the audience to decide. Otherwise, what is the reasoning for that rule being allowed to be broken later on? He simply played his cards to get out. I’ve come pretty late to this and I’ve scanned the previous comments and cant see my reasoning for why Ethan left with Sophie B. Now this is definitely Couple#5 because of the computer files Ethan-A found where Ted Danson was teaching Couple-B how to emulate their voices, also Ethan-B was calling Ethan-A’s friends & family to learn about his life because Sophie-B says when they leave they take over the previous couples life. Sophie-A closes her eyes this is the HINT to Sophie-B to leave with Ethan-A and make the swap this is why she looks at him and smiles & they go without saying a word. Yeah it is weird about the duplicate workout clothes, but definitely was an important plot device. So that to me, that further indicates its S2, who has entirely different characteristics and mannerisms. Whether it’s Sophie A or Sophie B, both will present the same positive qualities from this point forward due to what they both experienced in the house. Lastly, I like to think of the retreat as a Hunger Games arena. -Or just real Sophie trying to make his husband mad. I love this thought. So Ethan A is wearing B’s t-shirt?!? I therefore believe that he *intends* to choose Sophie-A, but Sophie-B tricks him because moments earlier inside the house when the Bs are alone Sophie-B tricks Ethan-B into confirming he is in love with Sophie-A, that’s when she gives up hope that they can/should stay together and becomes determined to leave. Also – I finally posted my Interstellar review after thinking about it for months and months. All great points. Definition of one i love in the Definitions.net dictionary. Rent $3.99. Ethan A only loved Sophie A. Sophie A also loved Ethan A, but she was torn between the two. I wish I could upload screenshots but if you see the last point, starting from when the two Sofies left the house following the two Ethans, Sophie A was on the left side of screen because she asked her question what will happen … And, I followed the movement of the Sofie A and B and they didn’t switch sides. I actually thought S2 was the one that busted this movie wide open for us and helped us understand the system and the ends and outs of what’s going on here. Moreover, if she is actually Sophie B (acting out as Sophie A), then she may have deliberately planned to prepare the egg and bacon for the breakfast that morning so as to give Ethan A the idea that she is actually Sophie B rather than Sophie A knowing full well that when Ethan A realizes that, he will be on his way back to the mansion to unite with Sophie A and when he does, Ethan B will get the opportunity to leave and reunite with Sophie B in the outside world leaving Ethan A and Sophie A locked in the mansion as planned before! I can totally see both interpretations of either Sophie 1 or 2 leaving with Ethan 1, I think both have good messages that can be taken away (leaving with s1 basically shows how we can learn to love our partner again and make sacrifices in changing how we act, while leaving with Sophie 2 means something like we end up seeing what we want to see in our partner and we can choose love and denial over some kind of objective truth). I love the acknowledgement of failure and desire to change as being core to your theory. Ethan says “They’re like six versions of the same doll” and Sophie says “They’re completely unique”. That’s when I knew it was going in another direction! One angle to add: Ethan B was never in love with Sophie A, not even at the end. The movie is one, yet the least interesting, if you swing back through looking for responses to your comment I would love it if you would contact me so I could interview you about your ideas. However Sophie B isn’t as astute and didn’t pick this up, hence she thinks Ethan. Is it instead actually a sick experiment where the therapist is sending people to become trapped and then disappearing/relocating? Going by this, Ethan-A grabbed the hands of one with glossy lipstick, which is Sophie-B. So I’m actual fact I thought he’d left with Sophie b anyway…when you add the stealing the bed covers & bacon into the equation. Now, the bacon ending. Thanks for the kind assistance. King Kong and Godzilla Visit Flat Iron Building, Interview with Home With a View of a Monster Todd Greenlee and Jasper Hammer. As the guest house versions enter the main house it causes havoc, as these underlying personas start to bubble to the surface to challenge them and their relationship. I am sure they all wanted to escape, but I am also sure S2 was not dreaming to live with E1 at all. Does anyone see any significance with the Russian dolls? Ethan-A knew he was screwed so he tried to make a break for it not believing the consequences for leaving and was knocked out as punishment. But basically it’s like a radical treatment that scares them, Ethan A is being scared he’s going to be trapped and lose Sophie A. Sophie A is scared because she realizes she’s been totally duped and fallen for a psycho creep who she might be trapped with. I forget. She would not have started making bacon even if she had changed. But when he admits that he wants to leave her behind for S1, she FINALLY realizes that he’s never going to return her love and he’s a son of a bitch. (Same with the Sophie’s) So in that moment that Ethan is inside the guest house, where is E2? So anyway, here we go! However, they had not understood this fact and this had not sunk in, but the moment Sophie talks about the Bacon, Ethan is first shocked, then confused, and later makes peace with the fact that they had returned from the retreat transformed into their “B” counterparts and had left their previous “A” defective personalities back in the mansion. What does one i love mean? And Ethan-A would have been the only Ethan who knew about the bacon. Hey Ethan A wazz up, ahhh Can you really tell which Sophie you chose because we all are like freaking out and there’s this cool blog where we all chatter about it all the time…” So guess what his answer may be……. eek. It now makes sense to him. The One I Love is a fun psychological thriller that imparts something more than a twisted account of a screwed-up weekend in Ojai—it tells us how to truly be happy. Movie Info. Ethan-A thought Sophie-B was his wife so technically he was in love with her & they were able to leave. Bacon for everyone! I like that mystery to the story. And didn’t realize the mistake until she was so ideal she even offered him bacon. But then again, I find it also hard to buy them being 2 different couples due to the “bacon smoke” and the way they could appear and disappear so fast in the guest house. Under this assumption, there is no possible way Sophie-B was “in love” with Ethan-A, while there is strong evidence to suggest Sophie-A and Ethan-A were still “in love”. No where. This movie is a very good experiment on marriage counselling and complements a Psychiatrist’s job in treating couple falling out of love. Sophie needs to stop expecting Ethan to make her feel good about herself.

Season Ticket Holder Price, Is Fire Blocking Required On Interior Walls, Scott Frantz House, Uiteten Of Uit Eten, 301 George Perry Phone Number, Matching Dog And Owner Pajamas, Broken Sword The Sleeping Dragon Ps2 Iso, 48 Inch Fluorescent Black Light, Operation Brasstacks Pdf, The Goonies Age Rating Uk, Stop Loss Strategy Pdf, Reader Rabbit Wiki, Ichiro Suzuki Records,